WHAT A FOOL BELIEVES

The veteran singer and keyboardist covers much of the same ground that many of his contemporaries traveled, but his memoir is filled with charming surprises.

A lot of the surprises have to do with his co-writer. Reiser, best known as the star and co-creator of the sitcom Mad About You, gives McDonald’s stories the structure and pacing of a TV show. The resulting chapters—especially those about McDonald’s family and how his love for his father shaped his life as a teenage performer—fly by early on, even though they cover the lesser-known years of the acclaimed musician’s life. McDonald doesn’t offer many salacious details about his split with the Doobie Brothers following the success of the chart-topping hit “What a Fool Believes,” which won record and song of the year honors at the Grammy Awards in 1980. He is gracious about the band’s internal battles and forthcoming about his substance abuse without discussing the drug use of others. “My attitude was: coke should be reserved for a special occasion,” he writes. “But as time went on, I managed to christen more and more occasions as ‘special.’” The emotional heart of the narrative is his exploration of how he realized his addiction made it impossible for him to help his wife, the singer Amy Holland, battle her own problems. McDonald offers insights into the creation of some of his most famous songs, including “You Belong to Me” with Carly Simon, as well as his worries about tackling the Motown catalog for his career-boosting Motown album series. McDonald writes from a solid, self-aware place, able to joke about his position as one of yacht rock’s most famous voices, alongside Christopher Cross, Kenny Loggins, and others.

Like its namesake song, McDonald’s memoir is refreshingly self-deprecating and, at its core, an underdog’s triumph.