THE BEST THAT YOU CAN DO

Cultural loss, romantic disappointment, sexism, sexual violence, and the cost of racism are examined in close to five dozen stories told through the eyes of Black and Puerto Rican characters.

The biracial children in the stories in the first section, "Quarter Rican," are all pursuing their Puerto Rican heritage: by sneaking behind their mother’s back to learn Spanish, searching for Puerto Rican faces on TV reruns, or scouring the neighborhood for old men who might be their grandfathers. What they don’t know is how much their Black grandmother struggled after her Puerto Rican husband abandoned her, returning to the island and starting a new family. Told from a constellation of points of view, these stories, many of which are no longer than five or six pages, accumulate emotional force and capture the complexity of families and generational divides. Gautier is a master of the short-short story (often referred to as sudden fiction). Pieces like “My Mother Wins an Oxygen Tank at the Casino, or, My Mother Makes an Exception” and “Forgive Me” evoke the fierce love of daughters for their mothers in just two pages, and “Summer Says” swiftly captures summer’s pleasures in the Brownsville neighborhood of Brooklyn: “All summer we have the days to ourselves, the neighborhood to ourselves, and the streets are ours for the taking,” the children announce. “Each morning we are few, but by afternoon we are legion.” Sometimes, brevity does a disservice to Gautier’s subject matter, especially when she’s writing about women’s disillusionment with men. In “So Good To See You,” for example, a woman goes on a quasi-date with an old high school friend who spills gravy on his tie and thinks he’s a “good catch” just by virtue of not being in jail. This and a handful of other stories strike a single note and move on. Still, Gautier has a real gift for finding dignity and bravery in the lives of ordinary women. The collection’s final stories focus on Mrs. McAllister, an aging woman whose commitment to her family, especially her dead sister, may move you to tears.

A collection with so many important stories that some of the less successful ones could have been left out.