BRINGING BEN HOME

A thought-provoking cultural discussion of wrongful convictions based on race.

In 1987, Benjamine Spencer, a Black man, received a life sentence for a crime he did not commit: the brutal murder of Jeffrey Young, a white man, in Dallas. According to Hagerty, author of Life Reimagined and Fingerprints of God, this narrative—of an innocent person of color incarcerated without the benefits of credible witnesses, solid evidence, a competent investigation, or effective legal counsel—is disturbingly common. What makes this story distinctive, however, is the author’s keen understanding that each experience is unique to a specific individual. The concept of injustice may be monolithic, but the mechanics involved are far more complex than most people comprehend. “If Spencer’s experience could be captured in one sentence,” writes Hagerty, “it is this: Convicting an innocent person is easy; undoing the mistake is almost impossible.” The author’s narrative persuasively demonstrates how deeply embedded racism is in the fabric of the American criminal justice system. Unfortunately, few people heroically advocate for the wrongly imprisoned. In this case, the hero is Jim McCloskey, a Vietnam veteran and priest who has been instrumental in the modern innocence movement and aided Spencer in his fight for freedom until 2021, “when he became one of the rare prisoners in America who persuaded a prosecutor to take a second look at his conviction.” The description of the emancipation process is occasionally a slog, but Hagerty skillfully interweaves details of relevant past cases and historical commentary about how the justice system consistently moves the goalpost to punish Black Americans. Thankfully, the story has a satisfying conclusion, but it’s disconcerting nonetheless. Hagerty’s work will appeal to readers of Bryan Stevenson’s Just Mercy and similar books.

A stirring account of a legal travesty that effectively reveals a rotten core within the justice system.