MISSING

After several years of rootlessness following her mother's death, Thea and her Dad start to find a home for themselves when he takes a job renovating an old guest ranch in the Canadian Cariboo. Thea likes the ranch owner, who plans to breed Quarter horses, and she makes friends with a boy her age, Van, who lives across the lake. She's not sure what to do about Renegade, the neglected horse that came with the property—horses belong to the life she had when her mother was alive. When a guest shows up to stay at the ranch, Thea slowly starts to connect her to the mysterious death of a little girl that occurred over 50 years ago. Citra's writing is solid, and Thea is strong and appealing, but the story feels split. The mystery takes up most of the pages, but the horses seem to take up most of the emotion, and the two sides don't blend. Parts of the horse story don't make sense. Why would Renegade still be on property left empty for three years? Why do the adults, all professional horsemen, leave him entirely alone? Thea's Dad's character is inconsistently developed and muddled, and it's not clear why Thea is supposed to be angrier with her mother than with him. Even with all that, it's not bad overall, but still—better to tell only one story and do it well. (Mystery. 8-12)