THE PERFECT CRIMES OF MARIAN HAYES

A woman falls in love with the man who attempted to blackmail her.

This novel opens with a retelling of the events that ended the first book in the series, The Queer Principles of Kit Webb (2021), but from the point of view of Marian, Duchess of Clare. Trapped in a loveless marriage and recovering from a near-fatal pregnancy, Marian is outraged when a blackmailer threatens to reveal that her husband is a bigamist. If the news became public, it would invalidate her marriage and render her daughter a bastard. Rob Brooks has his own personal reasons for blackmailing Marian, but as they exchange letters, he’s surprised to find himself admiring her moxie. She informs Rob that she won’t pay the blackmail since she has her own plan to neutralize the threat of discovery. Her scheme goes terribly wrong, and she has no choice but to shoot her husband. Fearing she’ll be arrested, Rob helps Marian flee London on horseback. They plan to hide at her father’s country home until the coast is clear. Marian and Rob must trust each other to survive the journey, which is full of rollicking adventure. Their friendship and romance are emotionally satisfying, with both Marian and Rob determined to make it in the world on their own terms. The plotting fails to find its footing after the propulsive first act, but the sharp writing and likable band-of-thieves vibe is its own reward.

Sebastian’s hallmark witty banter and charming characters will keep readers invested in spite of the disjointed plot.