THE ORPHEUS PLOT

A young Belter cadet deals with a rebellion in space.

Lucas Adebayo’s dream has come true: He’s the first Belter cadet in the Earther Navy. Well, the first openly Belter cadet—the true first was his adopted sister, Tali Chen, who’s posing as the only Martian. Though Tali’s actions are understandable given the Navy’s history of bias against people from the asteroid belt, who are marginalized and disdained by those from Earth, Luna, and Mars, Lucas is hurt that Tali doesn’t want anyone to know they are siblings. After Tali discourages him from joining the Navy with ambiguous, ominous warnings, Lucas sees her planting a device on the ship’s hull, investigates, and a rebellion plot unfolds. Lucas wrestles with guilt over his enjoyment of being in the Navy, loving the thrill of the chase but feeling conflicted about arresting Belters for relatively minor infractions while knowing how devastating imprisonment will be for them. Unfortunately, the theme of marginalized communities seeking justice is presented without nuance in a way that feels culturally disconnected from current events and seems to equate identity and difference with conflict while erasing the fundamental problem of an existing imbalance in power. The narrative’s assertion that the oppressed simply need to talk with their oppressors to bring about change feels simplistic at best, undermining what is otherwise a well-paced and well-plotted book. Racial and ethnic diversity are suggested through names.

Disappointing.