PLACE OF PASSAGE

The editors of this charitably sized volume have selected a wide variety of verse and arranged them according to the liturgical calendar. The poems thus cluster around the larger ceremonies of Epiphany, Lent, and Easter, but many of the Saints’ Days are also examined (among them St. Cecilia, St. Anthony, and St. Thomas Aquinas). In the editors’ opinion, it is the Catholic poet’s “emphasis on the sacraments,” and the wealth of symbolism to be found there, that distinguishes them from other Christian poets. Works such as Denise Levertov’s “Daily Bread” or Kevin Fitzpatrick’s “Breakfast Dishes” are instructive in this sense. Many of the poets will be unfamiliar to most readers, and some (such as John Paul II, Annie Dillard, and Thomas Merton) are not primarily poets. The more well-known figures include Levertov, Les Murray, and Robert Fitzgerald. These poets do not always show to advantage in the selections here: Murray’s stentorian “Poetry and Religion” reads strangely when taken away from the embattled, idiosyncratic context of his collections, and Fitzgerald’s virtues as a translator of the classics—his dense yet lucid lines—often sound stilted in his own poetry. The other works are uneven. The editors have chosen to lead off with two poems of the Pope, poems that “provided some of the direction of the anthology.” The decision is perhaps an obvious one for believers, serving as a statement of purpose, but it is a highly questionable decision from an outsider’s perspective, since both poems deal in plodding abstractions and traditional, inwrought symbolism that make for difficult reading.

One senses that most of these poems are mere preaching to the choir.