GANGSTERLAND

On-the-ground tour of places, extant and extinct, where key episodes in New York’s organized crime history took place.

“Few of the characters we meet here end well. Fewer deserve to….Just don’t turn your back on anyone,” writes Pietrusza at the beginning of this wide-ranging compendium of people and places. It’s good advice, for even if one of those scenes has since become “the much more respectable site of a Whole Foods,” there are still plenty of criminal venues that still stand today—though most have been repurposed. For instance, the old Knickerbocker Hotel, on 42nd Street and Broadway in the heart of today’s theater district, was once a hangout for the gangster Arnold Rothstein (about whom Pietrusza has written a biography), enjoying a dining room captained by a budding restaurateur named Vincent Sardi. Rothstein used the Knickerbocker as a venue for his “high-stakes floating card and craps games,” and the hotel was also, conveniently, where his lawyer kept his office. The Knickerbocker may now be a condominium complex, but the spirits of gangsters and patsies, to say nothing of onetime resident F. Scott Fitzgerald, still hang over the place. Though he made a decent buck arranging such events as the Chicago “Black Sox” throwing of the 1919 World Series, Rothstein was mortally shot at a nearby hotel for, by one account, having run up one too many unpaid debts. As Pietrusza notes in passing, though the World Series scandal took place in Chicago, it was a New York–born scheme—and a New York journalist took the lead in exposing it. William Randolph Hearst, Jimmy Durante, Babe Ruth, W.C. Fields, Damon Runyon: All figure in these spry pages, featuring countless episodes of the bad behavior that New York’s gangland concocted. The book includes a chronology and cast of characters.

An entertaining, sometimes grisly stroll through Gotham’s bad old days.