ALONG CAME GOOGLE

The story of Google’s early attempt at creating a universal library with its “promises of making all the world’s information available to everyone.”

Marcum and Schonfeld, both of whom have long experience in the library world, begin their examination of the Google Books project by discussing the concept of a universal library, a “comprehensive library that is accessible to all,” an idea that dates back to the Great Library of Alexandria. In 2004, in the early days of information digitization as a practice, Google announced its plans to “allow simultaneous searches of ‘billions of web pages and texts of hundreds of thousands of books.’ ” After introducing Google’s vision, the authors chronicle the history of resource sharing in libraries, from the card catalog at the Library of Congress to the creation of interlibrary loan services and online databases. Then they move on to the specifics of Google’s ambitious project, which began with a partnership with five renowned university libraries and a number of publishing companies and ended up leading to the creation of a number of similarly themed projects. By sharing the views of both the librarians who supported the concept and those who were concerned about a library for everyone being controlled by a private company, the authors offer a nice overview, including the mechanics of the initial project, objections from publishers about copyright issues, and the court case that would ultimately decide the fate of the project. Throughout the heavily researched text, which benefits from interviews with librarians and other information professionals describing their experiences in “the early days of digitization,” the authors keep readers informed, despite dryly academic passages, of just how widely “the entry of Google into the library arena” would affect information sharing and librarianship today.

Sometimes too scholarly, but its contribution to the Google-vs.-publishers debate is well worth the jargon and technical terms.