Kirkus Reviews QR Code
THE TALKING STICK by Donna Levin

THE TALKING STICK

by Donna Levin

Pub Date: April 23rd, 2024
ISBN: 9781648210310
Publisher: Arcade

A woman and her former friend run rival support groups in Levin’s comic novel.

Hunter Fitzgerald suffers one indignity after the next. First, she loses her job when the fitness center she manages shuts down. Then her husband, Peter, leaves her for her newly sober friend, Angelica, a longtime partier and sponge whose memoir has just hit the bestseller list. Peter tries to sell their house out from under her just as Hunter realizes he’s destroyed her credit by maxing out credit cards in her name. Finally, while working at her new job at a Starbucks, Hunter learns that Angelica has trashed her in the memoir, accusing Hunter of allowing Angelica to get raped while they were out drinking one night. Hunter’s luck finally changes when, during an oppressively foggy day at a Bay Area flea market, she acquires a “talking stick” from a mysterious woman in an airstream trailer. “It was given to me by a woman I knew in an artists’ colony in New Mexico,” the woman tells her. “It’s been passed down from mother to daughter and used in female-only groups. Sometimes to settle a dispute among the women.” Upon receiving the stick, Hunter knows immediately what she needs to do: form a for-profit support group for women focusing on physical and emotional health. The first meeting, held at Hunter’s now for-sale house, attracts a not-quite-promising group of three, including Penelope, an elderly hypochondriac obsessed with dying; Dannika, a young woman who can’t get into college and is still mourning her dead mother; and Alicia, an OB-GYN who refuses to date out of concern for her teenage daughter. Meanwhile, Peter—who also retains access to the house—allows Angelica to use it to start her own, larger support group, the Fourteenth Step, in the room next to Hunter’s group. Despite her reservations, Hunter sticks it out with her sad trio, and the four of them begin to help one another get past the barriers that have been keeping them from happiness. But can they help Hunter save her house from Angelica’s growing army of supportees?

Levin writes with tenderness and humor, capturing the particular insecurities of each character. Here, Dannika hopes that friendships will develop between the members of the group, even as she frets about being judged by the other women: “Penelope’s house was a little closer to Dannika’s, but it was even swankier than Hunter’s, which made her feel embarrassed about her own place, with its old, cat-and-dust-covered furniture. True, the talking-stick women probably wouldn’t visit her often. Or ever.” Hunter, a California Republican and proud atheist who collects potentially valuable Barbies that she finds at flea markets, is a memorable and utterly believable character. It’s a pleasure to see her heart softened by the equally specific members of her support group. The book is perhaps longer than it needs to be at nearly 400 pages, but readers will enjoy the extra time they get to spend with these characters.

A funny and occasionally touching novel about rebuilding your life after a crisis.