THE LIVING AND THE LOST

After finding refuge from the Nazis in America, a young Jewish woman returns to her native Berlin in 1945, as the Allied occupation begins.

As we learn from flashbacks, Millie Mosbach and her younger brother, David, fled Germany as teenagers in 1938, sponsored by a generous American couple. Now Millie, a graduate of Bryn Mawr, and David, an American military officer and combat vet, have signed up for official duties in their homeland—Millie as part of a de-Nazification program, David to help with displaced persons. Millie is in turmoil, though, holding out hope that their missing parents and younger sister may still be alive—and hiding what she sees as a shameful secret about her escape. This book feels different from other historical novels about the Holocaust, partly because of its postwar Berlin setting. Author Feldman offers nuance, even irony here. While not giving any slack to the evildoers, she reminds us that some ordinary Germans also suffered under the Third Reich—Millie meets one woman whose son was murdered by the Nazis because they thought he was “mentally infirm.” The author also reminds us that antisemitism was rife in the U.S. when this story takes place. (Gentlemen’s Agreement, Laura Z. Hobson’s novel about discrimination against American Jews, was published in 1947.) Feldman’s writing is mostly workmanlike, though her description of the shattered Berlin—a “bombed out Wild West”—is striking. The last section of the book disappoints. It turns out that Maj. Harry Sutton—Millie’s boss and love interest—has been harboring a secret too much like Millie’s. Millie also falls and bloodies herself—literally—once too often, with Harry always rescuing her. In general, loose ends get tied up too neatly.

An often thoughtful and affecting page-turner, some clumsy plotting aside.