THE ROAD TO SUGAR LOAF

Reynolds offers a novel set during the final decade of the battle for women’s suffrage in the United States.

One morning in May 1912, in the small town of Sycamore Falls, Kansas, Kathryn Wolfe is opening the Main Street Bookshop, which she co-owns with her friend Mary Dodd. Their book-display table features a new arrival: Women’s Suffrage: A Short History of a Great Movement. Kathryn and Mary are both dedicated suffragists, and they’re working with other women in town to organize an event in support of the Equal Suffrage Amendment to the state constitution, scheduled for a November vote. They meet under the guise of a women’s club dedicated to discussion of more “appropriate” subjects, such as “education, child labor, and library creation.” However, men in town form their own club to fight the amendment, and the community atmosphere becomes confrontational, especially during a July parade in which suffragists are met by hecklers. After Kansas voters approve the amendment, Kathryn, Mary, and her growing group of suffragists turn their attention to Washington, D.C., joining the March 1913 walk for voting rights during Woodrow Wilson’s inauguration. Reynolds parallels his primary narrative with Kathryn’s personal struggle: She was injured in a fall several years ago, which left her with a limp, and she’s determined to one day reach the summit of Sugar Loaf Hill. The author also effectively provides additional drama in a disturbing side plot about the marriage of one of Kathryn’s friends, which is scarred by infidelity and domestic violence. The overall character development is minimal, however, and the pace ambles a bit too casually. The most engaging section covers Kathryn’s yearlong participation in the picket line outside the White House fence, beginning in February 1917. Here, Reynolds’ prose becomes more impassioned as he describes the increasing violence the women faced; in November 1917, for instance, Kathryn is sentenced to two months in the Occoquan Workhouse, a hellhole where she is dragged, beaten, and handcuffed to a bar above her head: “Cries and moans echoed through the corridors into the night.”

An often compelling historical overview but an uneven drama.