ORIGINAL SINS

A newly minted FBI agent reckons with her demons and faces Trump-era politics and toxic masculinity in the beginnings of a post-Covid world as she tracks down a serial killer who has re-emerged after 30 years.

Not long after the harrowing events of The Fields (2022), former Black Hawk County, Iowa, police sergeant Riley Fisher, now with the FBI, finds herself embroiled once again in a horrific investigation, this time set during a brutally cold winter in Des Moines. After disappearing into the ether for nearly 30 years, a masked man widely known as the Sin Eater has reappeared, leaving images of a snake and an apple near the body of his victim and sending the city into a panic. When the newly elected governor—the first woman in that position—receives a death threat, it falls to Riley to track down the Sin Eater before he can strike again. Big-city politics take center stage as Young attempts to illuminate the struggles and violence faced by so many people, often without justice, and the difficulties women contend with in male-dominated fields. Riley is a complex and compassionate character who grapples with her own trauma, reckoning with how it’s shaped her while also attempting to move on from it. She struggles with the guilt of leaving her young niece back in Black Hawk County while her family is still healing in the wake of the events of The Fields, and she becomes frustrated with a new partner who might not be on the up and up. Her resilience and tenacity as she’s thrown curveball after curveball—in both the case and her personal life—will have readers rooting for her as she puts the pieces of the mystery together. But while Riley’s character contains nuance, the other characters feel two-dimensional and fail to help this installment stand out.

A somewhat predictable and heavy-handed thriller.