THE FIELDS

An Iowa police officer investigates a gruesome series of murders in this scathing indictment of big agriculture.

Consider yourself warned: British author Young’s debut crime novel, the first in a planned series, is grisly and dark, and readers who dislike gory scenes should be wary. Set in a version of America’s heartland that rejects salt-of-the-earth stereotypes, the book opens with a desperate, bleeding young woman fleeing an unseen menace through an Iowa cornfield. When her body is found by a local farmer the next morning, newly promoted Riley Fisher, Black Hawk County Police’s first female sergeant, realizes the dead woman is a childhood friend. The discovery brings back painful memories of trauma even as Riley struggles with family issues in the present. As more women disappear and disturbing signs of cannibalism are revealed, Riley begins to think the gruesome murders may not be the work of a single serial killer but part of a larger conspiracy that could reach far beyond the Midwest. An unsettling, foreboding atmosphere permeates the novel, mimicking the depression Riley fights to keep at bay and the region’s collective despair over economic loss at the hands of big agriculture. Young is at her best when she’s writing from Riley’s point of view: Riley’s battles with personal demons and casual sexism in the police department make her a solid foundation for a recurring series. But the complexity of the plot requires too many points of view—even the killer weighs in in overwrought asides—and Young is forced into too much explanation and exposition. She’s determined to shine a light on a real problem—the destruction of family farms to feed corporate greed—but the book’s overly complicated narrative gets in the way of her ability to simply tell a good story.

A complicated plot overshadows solid character development in this gory debut.