Kirkus Reviews QR Code
IT IS WOOD, IT IS STONE by Gabriella Burnham

IT IS WOOD, IT IS STONE

by Gabriella Burnham

Pub Date: June 30th, 2020
ISBN: 978-1-984855-83-1
Publisher: One World/Random House

As she deals with boredom and isolation after being uprooted to Brazil for her husband’s career, the wife of an academic forges interesting, fraught connections with two other women.

At the opening of Burnham’s debut, lapsed writer Linda is on the brink of leaving her historian husband when he learns that he has earned a visiting professorship in São Paulo. Rather than end the marriage, she travels with him, embarking on her own journey of self-discovery. Their university-provided apartment in São Paulo comes with a maid, Marta, who cooks and cleans, exacerbating Linda’s sense of purposelessness as she wanders the streets of São Paulo aimlessly or else sits at home feeling useless. Linda’s situation begins to change as she first takes up painting, finally finding a means of personal expression, and then meets Celia, a beguiling theater artist who serves as a vehicle for Linda’s self-discovery. Unfortunately, the novel falters slightly at the end; Burnham sets up Linda’s dynamic with Marta as an emotionally, socially, and socio-economically complex one that will inevitably lead to some kind of emotional breakthrough, but when it does, it feels forced and clichéd—even a little white savior–ish—and does not ring entirely true. In addition, the novel’s ambitious second-person narration becomes grating and strange at times. Nevertheless, the fact that the narrative is addressed to a man—Linda’s husband—lends it additional power, transforming it into a sort of feminist rejoinder to patriarchical dismissiveness of domestic work, a document of the unseen complexity of women’s lives, no matter how quiet. At its best, the novel is a subtle and adept character study that reveals the power of connections between women. The novel is buoyed as well by Burnham’s dreamy prose, with which she conjures memorable images of Brazil. Though the plot is not entirely coherent, specifically when it comes to the development of Linda’s relationship with Marta, the author’s psychological insight and skill in portraying the multifaceted nature of female friendship make for a compelling read.

A transporting debut that deftly probes the complex nature of relationships between women.