AGGREGATED DISCONTENT

An essay collection that navigates complexities of modern life and identity with intellectual rigor and personal reflection.

Walker, a freelance journalist, brings a sharp cultural lens to her subjects, such as a multitude of her experiences as a transgender woman, social media’s impact on self-image, and shifting perceptions and roles of feminism. Walker’s recollections as a trans woman inform each of the essays, offering personal views on as well as indictments of societal ignorance, pressures, and pop culture. The first half of the chapter “What’s New and Different?” centers on the author’s views of the movie The Devil Wears Prada. Of the female protagonist, Andy, a magazine editor’s assistant, Walker writers, “Her resentment [for her job]…is one that is rooted in class and a perceived upending of her rightful position therein.” The author theorizes that Andy’s tyrannical boss, Miranda, became that way due to misogynistic treatment, behavior the author deems “so common, so quotidian, so…relatable.” The essays combine incisive first-person tales with cultural commentary, although at times the pieces occur as non sequiturs, reading more like a string of polemical observations rather than a clear, sustained inquiry. The author’s tone ranges from formal to colloquial. Of random people mistaking Walker for a man, she writes, “You know who hates being seen as a man? Somebody who isn’t one. A woman, for example. Maybe even some of the ‘men’ reading this.” Her reflections on varying facets of self-transformation encapsulate the tension that runs through the collection, but while Walker’s prose is sharp and often witty, the book struggles to build a cohesive narrative. The essays occasionally veer into repetition, with some ideas revisited without offering new depth. Still, the collection is compelling in its ambition, and Walker’s sharp eye for cultural critique shines through, even when the essays don’t always cohere.

A promising debut, marked by insightful observations and moments of astonishing candor and critique.