WHAT MAGIC IS THIS?

Three tween girls dabble in witchcraft but discover the magic of friendship.

Eighth grader Sophia, along with friends Mia and Alexis, attempt to use Mia’s knowledge of witchcraft (gleaned from the internet) to cast spells. Together, they sit in a circle and call upon elemental spirits, each hoping to find a solution to their emotional wounds. Mia struggles with self-harm, Alexis grieves for her deceased dog, and Sophia is heartbroken thanks to feckless ex-boyfriend Aidan’s cheating, prompting her to cast a love spell to get him back. One by one, the spells appear to come true, but Sophia’s friends help her realize that she deserves a more empowering journey toward self-love. The narrative, told from Sophia’s first-person perspective, develops parallels between her absentee father and Aidan, sources of rejection that prompt her recovery. Sophia’s voice is humorously exaggerated and obsessive when referring to Aidan. The confessional style, written with reluctant and struggling readers in mind, features repetitive dialogue with little exposition. The narrative moves disjointedly through time, however, jumping between the present and flashbacks, before leaping two years into the future, which may cause confusion. The secondary characters unfortunately feel typecast rather than like well-rounded people. Mia’s sudden healing, for example, skips over the nuances of self-harm and her need for non-magical solutions. The book’s physical design offers greater accessibility for those with dyslexia. Main characters read white.

An uneven melodrama.