A well-intentioned picture book about flatulence that falls flat.
The Fart Detective solves some aromatic mysteries and educates the next generation in Broughton’s latest picture book.
Whoever smelt it, dealt it, right? Well, not always: Enter the Fart Detective. His job is to sniff out the culprit of the silent-but-deadly variety of flatulence. When a child passes gas in his classroom, he and his peers scramble out of the room to escape the awful smell. The scent eventually makes its way to the titular Sherlock Holmes–esque detective, who’s in search of the disagreeable smell’s source but not interested in shaming the perpetrator for their odoriferous actions: “Farts are funny, if not overdone. It’s not nice to embarrass someone.” In fact, the detective is so knowledgeable about the forensics of farts that he becomes a guest speaker in the aforementioned child’s class. Unfortunately, the class’s teacher wants to ban the Fart Detective from the school entirely. The lesson at the book’s core—essentially, not being ashamed of your natural bodily functions—is a valuable one, but the story can often get confusing. Several plot elements, like how the detective came to speak to a school without prior approval by the administration, are hard to put together. Broughton’s rhyming narration likewise misses the mark, as many lines don’t scan and pairings such as “fartin’” and “certain” just don’t work. Ross’ illustrations—mainly of the mustachioed, deerstalker-wearing Fart Detective himself—are bright and expressive but lack context.
A well-intentioned picture book about flatulence that falls flat.Pub Date: Nov. 16, 2023
ISBN: 978-0912350912
Page Count: 49
Publisher: Mill Mountain Press
Review Posted Online: Feb. 8, 2024
Review Program: Kirkus Indie
A nice but not requisite purchase.
A retelling of the classic fairy tale in board-book format and with a Mexican setting.
Though simplified for a younger audience, the text still relates the well-known tale: mean-spirited stepmother, spoiled stepsisters, overworked Cinderella, fairy godmother, glass slipper, charming prince, and, of course, happily-ever-after. What gives this book its flavor is the artwork. Within its Mexican setting, the characters are olive-skinned and dark-haired. Cultural references abound, as when a messenger comes carrying a banner announcing a “FIESTA” in beautiful papel picado. Cinderella is the picture of beauty, with her hair up in ribbons and flowers and her typically Mexican many-layered white dress. The companion volume, Snow White, set in Japan and illustrated by Misa Saburi, follows the same format. The simplified text tells the story of the beautiful princess sent to the forest by her wicked stepmother to be “done away with,” the dwarves that take her in, and, eventually, the happily-ever-after ending. Here too, what gives the book its flavor is the artwork. The characters wear traditional clothing, and the dwarves’ house has the requisite shoji screens, tatami mats and cherry blossoms in the garden. The puzzling question is, why the board-book presentation? Though the text is simplified, it’s still beyond the board-book audience, and the illustrations deserve full-size books.
A nice but not requisite purchase. (Board book/fairy tale. 3-5)Pub Date: Sept. 13, 2016
ISBN: 978-1-4814-7915-8
Page Count: 24
Publisher: Little Simon/Simon & Schuster
Review Posted Online: Oct. 11, 2016
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Jan. 1, 2017
BOOK REVIEW
BOOK REVIEW
More gift book than storybook, this is a meaningful addition to nursery bookshelves
A young child explores the unlimited potential inherent in all humans.
“Have you ever wondered why you are here?” asks the second-person narration. There is no one like you. Maybe you’re here to make a difference with your uniqueness; maybe you will speak for those who can’t or use your gifts to shine a light into the darkness. The no-frills, unrhymed narrative encourages readers to follow their hearts and tap into their limitless potential to be anything and do anything. The precisely inked and colored artwork plays with perspective from the first double-page spread, in which the child contemplates a mountain (or maybe an iceberg) in their hands. Later, they stand on a ladder to place white spots on tall, red mushrooms. The oversized flora and fauna seem to symbolize the presumptively insurmountable, reinforcing the book’s message that anything is possible. This quiet read, with its sophisticated central question, encourages children to reach for their untapped potential while reminding them it won’t be easy—they will make messes and mistakes—but the magic within can help overcome falls and failures. It’s unlikely that members of the intended audience have begun to wonder about their life’s purpose, but this life-affirming mood piece has honorable intentions. The child, accompanied by an adorable piglet and sporting overalls and a bird-beaked cap made of leaves, presents white.
More gift book than storybook, this is a meaningful addition to nursery bookshelves . (Picture book. 2-8)Pub Date: Sept. 15, 2019
ISBN: 978-1-946873-75-0
Page Count: 40
Publisher: Compendium
Review Posted Online: May 21, 2019
Kirkus Reviews Issue: June 15, 2019
© Copyright 2024 Kirkus Media LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Follow
Popular in this Genre
We can’t wait for you to join Kirkus!
It’s free and takes less than 10 seconds!
Already have an account? Log in.
OR
Sign in with GoogleTrouble signing in? Retrieve credentials.
Welcome Back!
OR
Sign in with GoogleTrouble signing in? Retrieve credentials.
