A SMILE IN A WHISPER

In Middleton’s novel, an old romance is rekindled when two ex-lovers face their past.

Thirty-one-year-old Evie Sutherland, who suffers from Crohn’s disease, lives a quiet life in the Orkney Islands in Scotland. She runs her parents’ tourist shop and café, does genealogical research for tourists, and writes romance novels under a pen name. Her dating life, on the other hand, is rather complicated, partly due to her self-consciousness about her illness and partly because she’s still not over her breakup with her first love—a famous London actor named Nick Balfour who used to spend summers on the island—even though it happened 13 years ago. When an accident at her parents’ shop injures the cook handling a catering job for a new TV production filming in town, Evie must take over, putting her in frequent contact with one of the executive producers—none other than Nick himself. The story is told through Evie’s and Nick’s third-person perspectives in different chapters and takes place in two different timelines. The earlier narrative unfolds mostly over teenage summers; Evie is 13 the first time she meets 16-year-old Nick and 18 when they break up. Middleton shows a real knack for creating realistic and deeply developed characters. Secondary players, such as Evie’s childhood friends Sunita Kumari and Fiona Groundwater, are vibrant, stable parts of her life, but are well developed in their own right. Nick’s private struggles with panic attacks, career mishaps, and a complicated relationship with his mother ground him as a character and make him sympathetic, as well. When the pair are reunited in the present day, it’s clear they both still have feelings for each other, and readers will want to find out what happened between them more than a decade ago—and hope to see them back together again.

An often charming tale of youth, forgiveness, and second chances.