A play by Nobel laureate Rabindranath Tagore serves as a source of hope for Jewish orphans in wartime Warsaw and, decades later, for Communist revolutionaries in the Indian state of West Bengal.
Jaryk Smith is just 9 in 1942 and living in the (real-life) Warsaw ghetto orphanage run by doctor and author Janusz Korczak when he plays the role of Amal—a sickly Indian child who dreams of worlds beyond his home—in the Tagore play Dak Ghar. Days later, the Nazis send all the area's Jews to the Treblinka death camp; Jaryk is the only one of Korczak's 200 charges to escape the gas chambers. In the displaced persons camp where he winds up after the war, he's reunited with Misha Waszynski, who had worked at the orphanage. Nearly three decades on, having immigrated to New York, Jaryk and Misha have become lifelong friends with a shared history. Despite being wracked by survivor’s guilt, Jaryk is beginning to explore a relationship with Lucy Gardner, a woman who works in the city’s employment agency. Their relationship is disrupted when Jaryk learns of Misha’s death thousands of miles away, in the Indian state of West Bengal, where he had traveled to help produce the very same Tagore play. Unsettled by his friend’s demise, Jaryk travels to India to retrieve Misha’s ashes and inadvertently gets embroiled in the Naxalite uprising, the Communist movement that sparked in 1970s India. Chakrabarti deftly explores the weight of history, a touching love story, and Jaryk’s heart-wrenching survivor’s guilt. Woven throughout is the play that teaches you not about life, but about dying. It prepared the orphans for the unimaginable, as Jaryk remembers. The narrative struggles under the weight of its responsibility to these compelling themes and shortchanges a few, such as the Communist uprising, while Jaryk’s internal struggles and love for Lucy stretch on for too long.
An impressive if occasionally labored debut.