SOMETIMES THE GIRL

A teen gets a job organizing and cataloging a chronically ill author’s possessions, an experience that helps her find her voice as a writer.

Pulitzer Prize–winning author Elsie McAllister has a “permanent A+” reputation thanks to her one novel, which is “read in every high school” in America. The recalcitrant and reclusive older woman has two goals: safeguarding her privacy and ensuring that the person she hires will do exactly as she wishes with her belongings. Holiday Burton’s desire to earn enough to go to New Zealand and work on farms with ex-girlfriend Maya is an incentive to take the well-paid job. Both McAllister and Holi have been manipulated by male gatekeepers who had their own selfish reasons to stunt each woman’s creativity. While sorting through McAllister’s possessions, Holi discovers secrets from her past that were suppressed to make way for her “Great American Novel.” Holi sees an echo of her own artistic self-doubts and vulnerability in the face of a similar exploitative power dynamic. Mason-Black’s prose sparkles with poetic beauty as Holi engages in introspective musings about collective mourning and how individual healing is possible only in community. The stunning descriptions bring vitality to and convey the languid beauty of the Amherst, Massachusetts, setting. This striking work shows the power of intergenerational relationships to fortify queer artists against erasure. The protagonists present as white.

Beautifully written and powerfully uplifting.