SCARLET IN BLUE

A painter who’s been hiding herself and her daughter for years plots revenge in Murphy’s psychological thriller.

It’s 1968, and teen Blue Lake has changed towns nearly 10 times in the last six years. Blue isn’t even her real name; she and her mother, Scarlet, pick new names for every move. All this time, Scarlet has been running from “HIM,” a mysterious man who apparently keeps tracking down the mother and daughter. Blue calls HIM the Shadow Man, but she’s never seen this person, nor his distinctive black Cadillac. She’s tired of constantly moving and ready to settle down, and South Haven, Michigan, seems as good a place as any. She quickly makes a friend, stumbles into potential romance, and hones her already sharp piano skills. But Scarlet didn’t randomly choose South Haven as their latest refuge—it’s where she plans to mete out vengeance, which entails appointments with psychoanalyst Dr. Henry Williams. It’s a plan that could have profound consequences for both herself and Blue. The author has crafted a quietly suspenseful tale—readers know from the beginning the startling thing Scarlet has planned while Henry, in alternating first-person narratives, digs into the past to learn all he can about his curious, deliberately vague new patient. The mother and daughter have their own narrative voices and share a complex dynamic; Blue feels the mother she loves is “suffocating” her, and Scarlet worries her maturing daughter is “less agreeable” than she once was. A string of mysteries further bolsters the tension as Scarlet begins exhibiting signs of paranoia and schizophrenia (has she really seen the black Cadillac?). This engrossing book’s latter half delivers surprises all the way to the end with a strikingly oppressive atmosphere lingering throughout, from the unrelenting winter snow in the opening chapters to the Lakes’ run-down house in South Haven.

A riveting story of family and the unease of harboring dark secrets.