Kirkus Reviews QR Code
WHY DIDN’T YOU JUST DO WHAT YOU WERE TOLD? by Jenny Diski Kirkus Star

WHY DIDN’T YOU JUST DO WHAT YOU WERE TOLD?

Essays

by Jenny Diski edited by Mary-Kay Wilmers

Pub Date: April 20th, 2021
ISBN: 978-1-5266-2190-0
Publisher: Bloomsbury

A collection of essays by a master of the form.

Between 1993 and her death in 2016, Diski wrote several hundred essays for the London Review of Books—some book reviews, some personal pieces, “reflections on the world and its stories for the most part,” according to Wilmers, longtime editor of the LRB, who selected the essays for this masterful new collection of her work. In nearly all of the pieces, Diski’s voice is sharp, wry, and entirely her own. Writing about Sonia Orwell, she notes, “there must be people who, during their lifetime, get their minds right enough not to feel bitterness as the end looms and they realise that nothing much else is going to happen to them apart from death.” She goes on: “But not many, surely?” Diski’s interests ranged from Jeffrey Dahmer to Princess Diana to her own arachnophobia. Whatever the topic, her fierce intelligence and formidable wit are always on display. Particularly moving is “A Feeling for Ice,” which Diski later expanded into a book, Skating to Antarctica (1999). She describes both a trip to Antarctica and her difficult childhood, and the connections she draws are surprising and profound. As Wilmer observes in the introduction, Diski “liked blankness of all kinds: white surfaces, uneventful days….A place that had never been looked at and never would be was best of all.” However, in essays on celebrity worship, tabloids, and pop culture, Diski also wrote about the kind of bustling chaos that seemed to have become emblematic of contemporary life. Here, too, the author’s prose has a crispness and clarity of expression that have been rarely matched. Within a single sentence she can exude both a seemingly effortless elegance and a fearless iconoclasm. For writers and readers alike, this new volume is a tremendous gift.

The crystalline quality to these extraordinary essays confirms Diski as one of the most talented writers of her generation.