Kirkus Reviews QR Code
STARS IN THEIR EYES by Jessica Walton

STARS IN THEIR EYES

by Jessica Walton ; illustrated by Aśka

Pub Date: Aug. 1st, 2023
ISBN: 9781338818802
Publisher: Graphix/Scholastic

Fourteen-year-old Australian Maisie and her mum, Jo, are enthusiastic lovers of all things nerdy.

After scrimping and saving, they’re finally on their way to Maisie’s first fancon. Above all, Maisie is excited to meet her idol, Kara Bufano, an actress who plays her favorite superhero and is an amputee like her. The convention has more surprises in store, including a new crush in 15-year-old artist and fellow fan Ollie, who is nonbinary and working the con with their dad. Maisie’s leg amputation was due to cancer, which is in remission but has left her with chronic pain and fatigue. Her ongoing treatments and mobility aids are portrayed as a natural part of ordinary life, as is her bisexuality. While the characters often discuss anti-ableist messages in ways that could be more organic, the lessons carry import. The story is strongest when letting Maisie, Ollie, and Jo express their personalities. It captures an intense one-day romance bonded by fan art and instant understanding. Ultimately, just as important is the love between Maisie and Jo, a quirky and tightly bonded duo who are there for each other through thick and thin. Candy-colored art makes the busy convention a delightful world of visual excitement and discovery for Maisie. Aśka’s strong character illustrations let every emotion be clearly understood. Maisie and Jo have light-brown skin; Ollie and their dad read White.

Cheerful and empowering.

(author’s note) (Graphic fiction. 12-17)