LIE UNTIL IT'S TRUE

A Los Angeles teen whose sister has just been found not guilty of murder becomes embroiled in another mystery in this follow-up to Live Your Best Lie (2023).

Amanda’s life has been a mess with all that’s happened with her sister, not least because Amanda started posting anonymously on TikTok about it—and now that Cora’s been exonerated, Amanda worries she’ll find out she’s behind the account. Amanda has struggled in Los Angeles, missing longtime friends Mallory, Cole, and Vince, who are in Colorado. Trying to escape the glare of media attention, Amanda flees to the Colorado mountains to stay with her aunt, who works at Mallory’s family’s hotel. But her friends have also had a rough few years. Vince’s mother is in jail, charged with the murder of Lillia Das’ grandfather. (Lillia’s a peer on the fringe of their group, and someone with whom Amanda shares a secret bond.) Readers will easily sympathize with Amanda’s earnest third-person voice. Many more secrets twist their way through this story involving several families in an insular tourist town, a true-crime documentary producer wanting to feature the Das case, and a ghost story connected to the hotel. Weaver packs a lot into this page-turner, interspersing flashbacks and online speculations about the various cases and leaving readers guessing throughout. Amanda, Mallory, and Cole are cued white; Vince is Latino, and Lillia is from Kolkata.

An engrossing, sprawling whodunit.