Kirkus Reviews QR Code
FRIENDS DO NOT EAT FRIENDS by Jill Esbaum

FRIENDS DO NOT EAT FRIENDS

From the Thunder and Cluck series

by Jill Esbaum ; illustrated by Miles Thompson

Pub Date: June 29th, 2021
ISBN: 978-1-5344-8652-2
Publisher: Simon Spotlight

Prehistoric prey and predator reach an accord in this graphic kickoff for fledgling readers.

Opening with a primer on graphic visual conventions and how to read panels in order, the tale introduces Thunder, a humongous theropod, and tiny, birdlike Cluck. From their first encounter, the latter, refusing to flee and seemingly undisturbed by all the roaring and tooth gnashing, launches a persistent campaign to winkle an admission of friendship from the former. In cartoon scenes of one to three big panels per page, Thunder’s indignant “That is not how this goes!” evolves in stages into a grumpy admission of defeat: “Something tells me hanging out with you will be…interesting.” If the vocabulary at times seems a bit advanced for the elemental art and plotline, it’s mostly spread out into easily digestible bits punctuated by wordless panels and more roaring. Many of Thompson’s panels are vertical, emphasizing the difference between burly, toothy orange-and-purple Thunder and scrawny Cluck, whom Thunder could easily swallow whole without noticing—but doesn’t. As unlikely friends go, this isn’t the weirdest pairing—trailing, for instance, William Steig’s Amos & Boris (1971) or Salina Yoon’s Penguin and Pinecone (2012)—but it’s extreme enough for even very young children to see the contrast as comical. (This book was reviewed digitally with 9-by-12-inch double-page spreads viewed at 80% of actual size.)

Droll dino fare for the lower reaches of the format’s audience.

(Graphic early reader. 6-8)