TILL DEATH DO US PART

Dark rumors lay the groundwork for another vintage locked-room puzzle from the acknowledged master of the form.

A mere six months after Lesley Grant’s arrival in Six Ashes, playwright Dick Markham has persuaded her to let him announce their engagement, thwarting all the villagers who’d been nudging him to pop the question to Cynthia Drew. There’s only one fly in the ointment, but it’s a whopper. Home Office Pathologist Sir Harvey Gilman, who, as The Great Swami, has been telling fortunes inside a tent at a local fete, informs Dick that his beloved has fatally poisoned two husbands and one fiance under impossible, and remarkably similar, conditions. No sooner has the pathologist finished his announcement than he’s shot through the tent by Lesley—accidentally, she maintains—and before dawn the next morning, while Harvey is still recovering from his wound, Dick, brought to the scene by an anonymous phone call, finds him poisoned to death inside a locked room. The mystery cries out for Dr. Gideon Fell, that expert in impossible crimes, and he solves this one brilliantly, though the actions he takes against the killer lead abruptly to another murder that somewhat dampens the closing pages. According to Carr biographer Douglas Greene, the puzzle turns on the author’s own “favorite gimmick” from his storied output, and devotees of the formula will devour it, and the prewar trappings that already made this a period piece when it was first published in 1944, with relish.

Even seasoned fans who spot the killer will be hard-pressed to explain exactly how this impossible crime was committed.