HOW WE WERE BEFORE

A startling double murder shakes a small American town in Kravetz’s debut novel.

Reporter Matt Foster, after five years at a weekly in Benfield, Massachusetts, has a line on a story that will appeal to bigger publications: 18-year-old Billy Lawson, during a burglary, shot and killed elderly Pete and Tara Blythe in their sleep. As Matt interviews Billy’s mom, will he become more devoted to the sympathetic woman than to his “juicy” news story? This is the first of 12 interlinked tales that highlight various characters in the homicide’s aftermath over the course of 2014. Shelby, the older of the couple’s two daughters, bonds with a local female reporter and debates what type of letter to send Billy in prison—scornful or empathetic. Shelby’s sister, Samantha, is estranged from her husband, Carlton, a sanitation worker with plans to confront the former police chief who had a hand (however inadvertently) in Billy targeting the Blythes. The author breaks up these stories with glimpses of Pete and Tara’s married life through the decades as they struggle with infidelity and the pressures of raising kids. Kravetz’s stellar characterization pays off in a series of profound turns as his cast question not only the horrifying crime but also their own lives. As these tales aptly reveal, such misfortunes as loneliness, alcoholism, and broken relationships may start with one or two people but hurt myriad others. Characters pop up in multiple stories, giving readers varied perspectives (Billy’s friend, Barry Epstein, seems both a troublemaker and a troubled soul). Throughout, the author ornaments the taut prose with metaphors that pack a punch (“Life is a broken jaw, always aching”; an end-of-the-workday body is “wrung out like a damp washcloth”).

A fascinating, potent examination of how a single violent act can spark endless repercussions.