KILLINGLY

The disappearance of a Mount Holyoke student in 1897 threatens to unearth any number of unholy secrets.

Most of the other residents in Porter Hall have little to do with Bertha Mellish, whom they regard as unstylish, plain, and not especially sociable. Even her senior mentor, the glowing and polished Mabel Cunningham, has little to say about her. Only two people are really close to Bertha: her much older sister, Florence, a schoolteacher back in Killingly, Connecticut, where they both grew up; and Agnes Sullivan, a fellow student who’s notably gifted at drawing but who dreams of becoming a surgeon. Unlike anyone else at Mount Holyoke, Agnes knows everything there is to know about Bertha—maybe even, as Beutner hints early on, what happened to her when she vanished from campus. When someone identified as Bertha Miller is reported to have been seen in a neighboring town, Bertha’s father, Rev. John Hyrcanus Mellish, goes to check her out but forbids Florence to accompany him. Later, Florence will go herself to identify the body of a young woman who’s been fished from a nearby lake. Both leads are dead ends, leaving it uncertain whether Bertha’s vanishing was connected to a series of petty thefts at the college; to Joseph Poirier, the unsavory millworker she’d taken up with; or to her home life back in Killingly. Beutner’s decorous prose effectively establishes a hothouse atmosphere, but the suspense endures without ever quickening, and after a shocking revelation halfway through, the rest of the story, rooted in an unsolved real-life Mount Holyoke mystery, seems to wind down rather than winding up.

Warning: serious violence against cats, who have a lot more to endure here than humans.