SILENCE IN THE LIBRARY

A patriarch’s murder disrupts the families of both the victim and the sleuth.

London, 1815. The unexpected arrival of her bullying father, George Pierce, shakes the fragile equilibrium of young widow Lady Lily Adler. Pierce even manages to insult courtly Capt. Jack Hartley, who’s been Lily’s most faithful supporter and friend ever since the death of her husband, Freddy. A social call on Pierce's longtime friend Sir Charles Wyatt and his new young wife turns awkward when Thomas the footman is accused of stealing a large sum of money, greatly upsetting his sister, Ellen the maid. The observant Lily dazzles the group by accusing Sir Charles’ nephew Percy, who turns out to be guilty. When Lily and Jack visit the Wyatts the next day for a horseback outing, they’re shocked to learn that Sir Charles has been murdered. This puzzling crime gives the fledgling sleuth an excuse to stay away from her new home on Half Moon Street, where Pierce has settled in for an indefinite visit. Impassive investigator Simon Page of the Bow Street Runners undertakes the investigation; Lily turns on the charm in order to piggyback onto his probe and strikes out on her own with Jack as wingman. Suspicion naturally falls upon heirs like Sir Charles’ devoted son, Frank, Pierce’s godson. Schellman’s gracefully written whodunit is equally a tale of 19th-century female empowerment and societal conventions. Depth of character and persuasive historical detail keep the pace leisurely.

More than a clever murder puzzle, this is an immersion in a bygone era.