ROUGH TRADE

Carrasco revisits the world she created in The Best Bad Things (2018).

When this story begins, Alma Rosales has left her past behind and reinvented herself as Jack Camp, smuggler. In partnership with her former lover, she controls the flow of opium from Canada throughout the West Coast from her base in Tacoma. When a double homicide threatens to put her operation at risk, Alma thinks she has the situation in hand—until it’s clear that she does not. Then two newcomers arrive in town. One is her former partner from the Pinkerton’s Women’s Bureau. The other is a journalist whose interest in the opium trade might become a problem. Carrasco introduced readers to Alma in her last novel, and the sequel is a similar mix of gritty historical fiction and crime. She repopulates the past with the queer people and queer culture that have often been erased from history. Carrasco does a terrific job of conjuring a port city at the end of the 19th century. Her description of the physical world her characters inhabit is evocative, but the carefully rendered setting only underscores their one-dimensional nature. It’s entirely possible that readers who enjoyed The Best Bad Things will want to know what happens next for its characters, but readers encountering them here for the first time may find them intriguing without being convincing. The author’s penchant for lingering over physical details also makes it difficult to appreciate this book as a mystery. The pace is just very slow—so slow that it’s not easy to stay invested in the story’s outcome.

A novel that straddles a couple of genres without quite satisfying the demands of either.