IN LIGHT OF ALL DARKNESS

An in-depth account of the lengthy investigation into the 1993 abduction of 12-year-old Polly Klaas from her home in Petaluma, California.

Cross, author of What Stands in a Storm, writes, “I am the daughter-in-law of Eddie Freyer, the FBI case agent in charge of the [Klaas case],” a connection that granted the author unprecedented access. She was drawn to this project in part because of the case's significance in terms of how it used technology “at the dawn of the Internet age” and investigative skills that, as one agent told her, “changed the way the FBI does business.” Over 42 tight chapters, each as searing as the next, Cross chronologically pieces together the narratives: the knifepoint “stranger abduction” during a slumber party at Klaas’ house; reports from neighbors and police of a trespasser the same night; and forensics work of the FBI’s Evidence Response Teams (“these mavericks were initially considered rogues”) and their lifting of a partial palm print that ultimately helped to convict. The author accounts for all of the investigative angles and tactics, worthwhile and otherwise, in addition to logistics—e.g., reports being “handwritten or typed” and the challenge of a “paper-based lead-tracking system.” Word of Klaas’ disappearance spread via the news, word of mouth, and flyers. This suspenseful narrative includes the trails of clues that led to the arrest and conviction of Richard Allen Davis, who was found guilty of abducting and murdering Klaas. Cross points to the “brutal interrogation” of the victim’s two sleepover guests as “one of the biggest mistakes of the case." Despite her family’s involvement with the case, the author comes across as objective. Her credibility stems from her criticisms of systematic failures and her orchestration of innumerable personal and technical details, and she effectively humanizes the victim and others involved in the case.

A riveting tale that demonstrates the investigation's effect on solving cases even three decades later.