THE CINDER DROP

A pair of detectives contend with corruption while trying to solve a bizarre pair of seemingly unrelated murders in Elin’s mystery.

In 1969, police detective James Plishka’s life suddenly gets more complicated. The widower, who lives in Lackawanna, New York, is enjoying his burgeoning relationship with local waitress Jennifer Simon, but he’s having trouble connecting with his troubled teen son, Robert. His chief gives him a new trainee: Tom Baldwin, the only Black officer on the Lackawanna force. Baldwin, a former college basketball star, shoulders his own burden—he was promoted over white cops with more experience, which isn’t earning him any new friends. A reluctant Plishka brings Baldwin up to date on his cases, including the mysterious death of honor student Sarah Simpson. Then a call comes in about a body found at the cinder drop, where Bethlehem Steel dumps molten slag into Lake Erie. The deceased is identified as radical priest and lawyer Martin Goezina, who has cases pending against both the steel company over environmental concerns and the city regarding a proposed housing development. The detectives discover a connection between Simpson and Goezina—they’re both tied into a book the latter was writing that would expose government officials, businessmen, and drug dealers in the U.S. and Honduras. They have so many suspects and so little time. The author spent a quarter-century in the entertainment business, and his cinematic vision is evident in this debut novel. He vividly captures that pivotal moment when, amid a counterculture revolution, citizens started to question the noxious side effects of the U.S. steel industry. Racism plays a prominent role in this novel (“There are about ten thousand very angry white people in this city who would do almost anything to stop that housing development”), though the most conspicuous evil on display is greed. Elin’s relatable protagonists are both at personal crossroads, earning readers’ sympathy as they gather a diverse team of allies, doggedly plugging along until the case reaches a shocking but satisfying conclusion.

Both a complex thriller and a well-drawn period piece.