LEGACY OF HONOR

In this historical novel, an American soldier braves the perils of World War I in France and falls in love with a nurse.

Sam McCormick tragically loses both his parents when the Lusitania is sunk by a German U-boat; they were sailing to England to visit relatives. Hungry for vengeance, he joins the National Guard in 1916 in Wellsville, Ohio, and soon finds himself on the war’s front lines in France, an infantryman who is part of the Rainbow Division. Now a sergeant, Sam is repeatedly exposed to the “terrifying trip into hell” that is combat and the despairing “orgy of death” that is war. He suffers multiple gunshot wounds and a mustard gas attack and twice finds himself sent to a field hospital. The first time, he meets beautiful French nurse Marie Petit and all but instantly falls in love with her. They maintain an epistolary romance conducted under the bleak specter of the war’s uncertainty. In this series opener, Freeland deftly captures the reality of the “life of a front-line doughboy” and the nearly indescribable grimness of a war that seemed interminable. The author clearly aims for literal realism—depicting a field hospital in Château-Thierry, he evokes “the odor of dead and decaying men” as well as the moans and cries of frightened, desolate soldiers. In addition, the plot marches along at a relentless pace—Sam sees plenty of action, with his military adventures culminating in the “monumental battle of the Meuse-Argonne.” But this is a familiar story that rarely departs from the formulas of the genre. For readers with even a cursory knowledge of novels depicting modern wars, there is not much that’s original here. Moreover, the author’s writing is sometimes bland, and the book strikes an earnest, sentimental tone. At one point, musing about Marie, the protagonist thinks: “I’ve never felt this way about a woman before and have no idea how to deal with my feelings. This is not going to be easy!”

A gritty, action-packed, but uneven war tale.