GRACIE UNDER THE WAVES

Gracie convinces her parents to take her and her little brother, Ben, snorkeling in Roatán.

Though her ultimate snorkeling goal is the Maldives, Korean American Gracie knows that baby steps are necessary to get her family from New York to the other side of the world, so she compromises by suggesting Honduras for spring break. Gracie also knows that patience is key when dealing with impulsive, boundary-crossing Ben. Gracie finds joy in seeing fairy basslets, butterflyfish, and other marine wildlife, but as Ben’s behavior grates on her and she learns about the threats faced by the world’s reefs, she’s brought to her boiling point. Gracie’s attempts to engage Ben in her interests fail to create a cohesive story. Her parents also leave her to do more than her fair share of caring for Ben—a choice that the author never unpacks or pushes back on. Frequent lectures from those who run the dive shop and the local marine park offer valuable information about protecting reefs but feel preachy and clunkily inserted. Ben behaves more like what an adult thinks a 6-year-old talks and acts like. While some readers may share Gracie’s passions, her descriptions of snorkeling and fishing are often disrupted by inorganic language and actions. Final art not seen.

An imbalanced mesh of sibling squabbles and overly didactic reef advocacy.