A divorce ripples through a close-knit group of friends in Palmer’s latest novel.
Three couples in fictional River Mill, Massachusetts—Mickey and Mateo, Abe and Amy, and Louisa and Nathan—have a 10-year tradition of gathering for each person’s birthday at an Italian restaurant.At this year’s dinner,on Nathan’s 40th birthday, he tells Louisa that he wants a divorce, which blindsides her. It turns out that Nathan, a college professor, is having an affair with one of his students. As his and Louisa’s marriage falls apart, their friends begin to reevaluate their own relationships. Amy and her husband, Abe, are having fertility issues, and although he can’t wait to be a father, she isn’t sure that she wants kids at all. She struggles with guilt as she loves Abe but doesn’t feel that she can give him everything he wants. Mickey and Mateo’s relationship is having trouble because they have mismatched libidos; Mickey pitches the idea of attempting an open marriage, which seems to work, at first, but gets complicated when their teenage daughter finds out about the arrangement. The opening sections of the novel are a bit confusing, as Palmer presents all six characters and their issues at once, from various points of view. Most of the book, however, focuses on the fallout from Nathan and Louisa’s split and how it not only affects their friends, but also their careers. Nathan acts in an appalling way, tying himself in knots to justify his affair; it makes it difficult to sympathize with him, and it’s unclear here the story’s sympathies lie. Louisa, meanwhile, faces condescension, not only from Nathan but also from her boss. But although some of the major and minor characters are distinctly unlikable, the complex story does feel true to life. Not all of the relationships survive, but their resolutions all feel authentic to the characters.
A realistic, if sometimes-frustrating, portrayal of couples facing emotional crises.