THE EVOLUTION OF ANNABEL CRAIG

A Tennessee woman is swept into the 1925 Scopes Monkey Trial when her camera skills get her a front-row seat at the proceedings, causing her to grow away from her upbringing.

A native of Dayton, Tennessee, Annabel is working as a housekeeper at a hotel when she meets and marries George Craig, a lawyer come to town to start his career, but the honeymoon ends when a client George got acquitted commits a horrific act of violence. George’s spirits and career get a boost when he joins Clarence Darrow’s team, which is defending the teaching of evolution in public schools. Annabel navigates the shoals of her marriage and tries to square her traditional beliefs with the positions of Darrow—and her husband, who belittles her for being provincial and uneducated. Nevertheless, as an avid amateur photographer, she’s thrilled when Lottie Nelson, a "lady reporter" she and George are putting up at their house, hires her to take pictures for the Chattanooga News. Although Grunwald’s research is admirable, she can disrupt her own narrative with anticipatory statements. For example, when Lottie files a story disclosing George’s negative views of the trial judge, rather than letting the consequences unfold, Grunwald has Annabel say, “I guessed that her story would be exceptionally long. I didn’t guess that it would also be exceptionally destructive.” Two pages later, we learn just how damaging the story is. In considering the pros and cons of the South, Annabel can be simplistic, but she does offer some important insights. “Women made the small decisions and men made the big ones. The small decisions often had the biggest consequences, like how a family handled hardship, or how far a dollar could be stretched, or what a child was taught to believe. But the big decisions made more noise.”

Provides a sense of how it felt to be in Dayton at the time of the Scopes trial.