PLAIN OFFENSE

A formerly Amish young woman investigates mysterious deaths in her old community in Qnert’s mystery novel.

Sadie Beiler has made an authentic life for herself outside of her family’s Amish community in Lancaster, Pennsylvania. As Sadie states, “I only have a handful of friends. I struggle to afford basic necessities. I’m floundering to find a faith that feels right. And I only have myself to rely upon. But I am free.” She lives next to her fellow ex-community member and best friend, Eli, with whom she often commiserates about their strict upbringing. Though Sadie now lives in the “English” world, she still keeps in touch with her family. Following a recent spate of perplexing deaths among her family and friends, Sadie notes how many Amish residents of Lancaster County are ill. She goes into overdrive investigating what could be plaguing her former community. Eli begins acting strangely and acquires large quantities of rat poison; Sadie suspects her friend may be contaminating Amish farm goods. Additionally, her friend’s younger sister Leah goes missing, and Sadie promises to search for her; she also meets Miriam, another ex-Amish girl, whom she takes in and helps ease into secular life. Meanwhile, Sadie’s mother is sick and has growths on her arm where a local doctor has been administering “vitamin elixirs.” Told mostly through Sadie’s point of view, the narrative is periodically relayed from the perspective of “the captive,” a mysterious character who has been shackled and imprisoned by an unnamed jailor. In these chapters and others, Qnert does not shy away from tackling tough subjects (including sexual assault), particularly as they relate to the cultural customs and beliefs of the Amish. Perhaps the most fascinating aspect of the story is the focus on the predisposition of the Amish to “various genetic disorders” and their subsequent immunity to cancer, known as the “founder effect.” The prose is sometimes repetitive, but the story, with its unique premise, is engaging overall.

A fresh mystery with solid storytelling.