Kirkus Reviews QR Code
HOPE by Marc Levy

HOPE

by Marc Levy ; translated by Hannah Dickens-Doyle

Pub Date: May 11th, 2021
ISBN: 978-1-5420-2564-5
Publisher: Amazon Crossing

Fantasy and neuroscience make uneasy bedfellows.

In the 1990s, best friends and purported geniuses Josh and Luke are attending an unnamed university in Boston and moonlighting at the sketchy Center, "a private laboratory run by the company Longview, owned in turn by some enigmatic entity," and headed by the untrustworthy Professor Flinch. The two are making remarkable progress at transferring human consciousness to a computer, which raises the possibility that people might be able to "shrug off death and aging." Unsettling their friendship is equally gifted science student Hope, who falls into a passionate affair with Josh. Hope is the sort of fictional female free spirit given to buying live lobsters at a restaurant and liberating them back to the sea. “Beautiful Hope, so full of light and life,” also suffers the kind of migraines that, in a novel, don't bode well for her long-term future. Halfway through, the story jumps 40 years forward, into the life of Melody, a concert pianist who will have a perhaps not too surprising connection to Hope. Because the novel has been translated from French, it's hard to tell how many of the clichéd expressions are in the original, but there's certainly an excess of prose about “endless cleavage” and “pale, parted lips.” The harder Levy tries to explain the scientific reasoning behind his plot, the less convincing it becomes. Because the romance between Josh and Hope is so generic, it's hard to care whether it defies death, and it's hard to believe that the remarkable discoveries on which the plot rests would have been concealed from the scientific community. With a lighter hand, and enough character development to make the reader care about his protagonists, this might have been a touching fable about the survival of love.

A disappointing attempt to flesh out a fairy tale.