MANY DEADLY RETURNS

An anthology celebrating 21 years of writing by Northern England’s Murder Squad with 21 stories, eight of them new.

The celebration is largely a private affair, with long-standing members Ann Cleeves, Kate Ellis, Margaret Murphy, Chris Simms, Cath Staincliffe, and editor Edwards contributing three entries apiece. Of the remaining stories by former Squad members, John Baker’s “An Old-Fashioned Poisoning” shows a Victorian woman celebrating the passing of Alfred, Lord Tennyson, by arranging another death; the police officer in Chaz Brenchley’s “For Kicks” uncovers a lifelong pattern of abuse in the case of a teenager kicked into a coma; and the thrill killer in the late Stuart Pawson’s “Ultra Violent” is brought to justice by a highly predictable mistake. None of these outliers can match the best stories by the current Squad members. In Staincliffe’s “Scorpion,” another abused teenager strikes back at a shockingly unexpected target. “A Winter’s Tale” is Cleeves’ routine but expert probe into the murder of a rural woman with a reputation. The gangster’s widow in Edwards’ “The Other Life” comes home from a séance arranged by her cleaning lady to find that two of her late husband’s colleagues have targeted her home for robbery. The officer who solves the locked-room poisoning in Ellis’ “My Oleander” wastes no time in applying the lessons he’s learned on the homefront. Simms’ “Gaffed” follows a high-stakes meeting between an informant whose wife’s death freed him from a gang’s blackmail and the officer who’s promised him protection to its logical conclusion. And a pair of hospital patients battling formidable handicaps in Murphy’s “Still Life” turn to battle each other till they work toward a resolution as welcome as it is unlikely.

Worst feature: too many similar plot twists. Best: the sharply characteristic voices that emerge from all these tales.