A middle-aged romance writer’s affair with a younger man feeds her fiction in Pritchard’s third novel (Selene of the Spirits, 1998, etc.), which aspires to comment on the genre.
Single mother Prudence True Parker teaches Advanced Personal Journey at an Arizona community college, not a gig that’s exactly making her rich. In the public toilet of her local library, she has a chance encounter with cross-dressing Digby Deeds, better known under the name “Mildred Crawley” as a wildly successful romance author. Whimsically insisting their meeting was “divinely ordained,” the dying Digby/Mildred asks Prudence to complete his Savage Passion series. All she has to do is flesh out the plots he bequeaths her, and her financial worries will end. Then, while volunteering (for reasons too strained to recount) at an Indian charity event in Oklahoma, Prudence meets Ray Chasing Hawk, a handsome if slightly androgynous Comanche with whom she shares a night of passion. Returning home to Tempe, she resumes teaching and raising her increasingly independent 17-year-old daughter Fiona. But soon Ray comes calling, and before long he’s moved in. Quite a handy coincidence, since Mildred Crawley planned her next book as a white woman/Indian chief romance. Pritchard contrasts that fantasy passion with Prudence’s less-than-perfect affair with Ray, who is angry, narcissistic, secretive about his friendships with other women, and perfectly willing to live off her money. Readers may be as bewildered as Fiona by her mother’s enthrallment, though she herself (seen as a kind of Prudence-lite) has not chosen much better. Prudence gains new respect for Ray after he undergoes the demanding rites of the Sun Dance Ceremony, and Pritchard’s depiction of the Native American culture, refreshingly politically incorrect at first, now becomes sentimentally reverential. When he discovers that Prudence has been using him as a model for her fiction, Ray feels used, but tensions are all too easily resolved.
The quirkiness feels forced, the sex dreary. Pritchard fans will be disappointed.