THE ALLERGIC BOY VERSUS THE LEFT-HANDED GIRL

Decades after losing a legal battle, a Vietnam War veteran recounts his side of the story in Kun’s novel.

Jimmy Nail believes that his college roommate, Peter John “P.J.” Darbin, stole and published his novel, which went on to become a seminal work that’s the darling of critics, teachers, and young adults. This first-person retelling follows Nail’s fragmented thoughts as they slide from the past to the present and back again. What begins as a darkly comedic tirade against Darbin and the legal system turns into a disjointed unraveling of his life story, which includes a traumatizing tour of duty in Vietnam, the collapse of his marriage and family, and his young adulthood in Baltimore. As Nail’s early years take center stage, the book settles into a reliable groove as the protagonist presents sections of his own short novel and intersperses them with recollections of events from his own life. At the heart of all the stories is Nail’s relationship with his neighbor Poppy Fowler—in Nail’s novel, she’s called “Poppy Fahrenberg,” and in Darbin’s, “Poppy Fahrenheit”—who likes the awkward, allergy-ridden Nail (in both novels, he’s “Allie”). As the novel rolls on, readers get the feeling that Nail’s accusation is not so fantastical. Kun, the author of Eat Wheaties! (2020), effectively manages to keep all the parts of his protagonist together, maintaining a clear throughline in spite of Nail’s inability to remember events with any sense of order. The author also plays around with tone, including mimicry of J.D. Salinger’s Holden Caulfield as well as a watered-down impression of Kurt Vonnegut’s work. The imitations are a far cry from the original, though, and Kun does best when he allows the main character to speak in his own voice. The ending will certainly leave many readers shocked, but it elevates the work and gives it unexpected heft.

A moving work of wit and pathos.