Kirkus Reviews QR Code
THE INITIAL INSULT by Mindy McGinnis Kirkus Star

THE INITIAL INSULT

From the Initial Insult series, volume 1

by Mindy McGinnis

Pub Date: Feb. 23rd, 2021
ISBN: 978-0-06-298242-1
Publisher: Katherine Tegen/HarperCollins

Tress would kill to find out why her parents disappeared.

In small-town Amontillado, Tress Montor had a seemingly normal life until her parents disappeared. That was seven years ago. Now living with her negligent grandfather at his questionable exotic animal attraction, the high school senior has become a pariah among her classmates. The one person who may know what happened is Felicity Turnado, who not only used to be best friends with Tress, but was the last one to see her parents alive. Told in alternating chapters from each girl’s perspective, this thriller starts off as a slow burn with longer chapters establishing their personalities; the nature of the closed-minded, predominantly White town; and the mysterious disappearance. When Tress, bent on truth and revenge, sets up an interrogation of Felicity reminiscent of Edgar Allan Poe’s “The Cask of Amontillado,” the story accelerates evenly with shorter, taut chapters delivering the final shocks. The narrative’s changing timeline, as each girl remembers events from the past, answers questions and raises intrigue in equal measure; their experiences are gritty reflections of teen life. And in the true spirit of Poe, a black cat, in this case a panther from the zoo, adds another level of creepiness with intermittent free-verse poems told from its perspective. A sudden, nail-biting ending leaves the door open for the next installment of this duology.

A dark, Poe-inspired thriller that lives up to the gothic master.

(Thriller. 14-18)