FOUR WOMEN

Two sobering cases challenge an atheistic, alcoholic attorney in need of redemption in Shabel’s mystery.

Joshua Logan makes a lousy first impression. In this novel set in 1968, he’s introduced hungover and still in bed when he should be in a Miami Beach courtroom representing a client whose name escapes him. Belatedly, he wishes that he’d had stayed home last night and looked over three-years’ worth of prep work. “I had to stop drinking,” he ruminates. “One more time and my fucking license would be gone.” To his credit, Logan, a “lawyer to the poor,” fights the good fights. The client he has trouble recalling is George Benash, who fell into a vat of boiling sulfuric acid at the Anchor Chemical factory where he’s worked for 30 years, leaving him with extensive third-degree burns. Another case hits closer to home: His beloved aunt Helen Lieberman, a Jewish Holocaust survivor from Poland, calls him in a panic after the city’s political and legal powers-that-be move to evict her and her three friends from a building in Miami Beach, where they’ve lived for more than 10 years. Neither case is a slam dunk for the former washout basketball player–turned–car salesman—and eventual lawyer. It turns out the developer, Horst Hillenbrandt, who’s trying to evict Helen and her friends, has a dark past, and he’ll stop at nothing to unleash his army of bulldozers and cranes on the building. Both cases are engaging, and readers will root for Logan’s underdog clients. Shabel, a lawyer himself, conjures a blatantly biased judge for his protagonist to go up against; at one point, the jurist pronounces, in open court, “Are you ready to try this ridiculous case, Mr. Logan?” His clear bias may raise objections from readers who are seasoned court watchers, but it recalls other courtroom dramas, such as the film The Verdict(1982), as does Logan himself, who, like Paul Newman’s character in that film, struggles to get his act together. Overall, though, it’s Helen’s case that’s the most compelling, with its heroic defendants confronting their worst nightmare.

An effective David-and-Goliath courtroom drama that will satisfy fans of legal thrillers.