FUNDAMENTALLY

A comic novel about a U.N. program for ISIS brides.

Nadia Amin is a floundering academic going through a bad breakup and, if that weren’t enough, her relationship with her mother is hanging on by a thread. After she publishes an article about rehabilitating ISIS brides, Nadia is offered a position with the U.N. that she’s wildly unqualified for, heading up a program deradicalizing Islamist women. She jumps at the opportunity. Younis’ ambitious debut traces Nadia’s clumsy attempts to get a grip on her own program. The book is meant to be funny but much of the humor feels strained, and the prose is often clogged with irrelevant details (“my strawberry-infused shampoo,” to take one example) that, at best, slow the momentum and, at worst, are simply boring. The best parts have to do with Nadia’s past: her own break from Islam, and her relationships with her mother and with her ex, Rosy. But the present-tense of the novel, when Nadia heads to Iraq to work with the U.N., is less successful. Younis seems eager to explore the ethical ramifications of Nadia’s work. Nadia asks, “What’s the appropriate punishment for ISIS brides who didn’t commit any violent crimes? Can we detain people just because of their beliefs? Should we try to change their beliefs? Or can we create behavioral change without shifting ideological commitments?” But the book doesn’t really engage these questions adequately. Instead, the questions are simply repeated again and again while Nadia becomes fixated on a particular woman from the refugee camps at the expense of all the others.

An interesting premise is soured by strained humor and failure to engage with the author’s own underlying questions.