WITH YOU ALWAYS

In Olsen’s (The Girl Before, 2016) second novel, a woman learns that her handsome new husband isn’t quite what he seems, and then some.

When career-minded Julia Hawthorne meets lawyer Bryce Covington by chance while on a work break one day, she’s immediately struck by how handsome he is and how gentlemanly he seems to be. To her delight, he asks her out, and after a few blissful dates, Julia is smitten, and evidently, so is Bryce. Everything would be perfect if it weren’t for the fact that Julia's sister, Kate, with whom she’s very close, is suspicious of Bryce. Kate claims that Bryce seems contrived and too perfect and points out that he never talks about himself. Julia chalks it up to the fact that her ex (and only other serious boyfriend), Jake, was charming too at first, and that ended in disaster. Julia is thrilled when Bryce invites her to meet his parents, the enigmatic Reverend and his wife, Nancy. They mostly raised him, but they aren’t his biological parents, and they run the Church of the Life. When Bryce invites her to attend, she’s open to the experience, though she’s not overly religious, and the experience is a revelation. The congregation makes her feel welcome, and she instantly feels like part of the family. In a creepy turn, she’s later invited to participate in the Gathering, where the congregants eat strange-tasting wafers, drink bitter wine, and then, in euphoria, speak in tongues and attempt to achieve Oneness with God. As she becomes entwined with the church, she quits her job and becomes isolated from her friends and family, especially after she and Bryce get married. As Bryce becomes more controlling, Julia blames herself for nearly all of his bad behavior. Even when he starts hitting her. When Julia begins to dig into Bryce’s past, all hell breaks loose. Readers will cringe as they turn the pages in hopes that Julia gets out before it’s too late to reclaim herself and her life.

A somewhat predictable yet compulsively readable story of a woman in way over her head.