NO TRADE IS FREE

An attorney and Trump adviser lays into those who espouse a “radical free trade agenda.”

In his first book, Lighthizer, who advised both Trump and Reagan on international trade policy, advances a host of familiar populist and nationalist themes—e.g., that in the matter of the suffering manufacturing and blue-collar heartland, “most people in DC didn’t worry very much, because it was all happening someplace far away to people they didn’t know.” Free trade, of course, has implications that stretch far beyond mere commerce and economics. For example, it’s a useful way of keeping wars from breaking out among trade rivals, which is in keeping with the author’s insistence that “the Chinese government is a lethal adversary” best contained by lowering taxes on corporations so they will stop offshoring jobs that should be American. Econ 101 may tell us that the specialized division of labor and comparative advantage are useful things, but they have little place in a vision of a world where everything is made at home by contented workers with lots of theoretical bargaining power—until they actually try to use it. Lighthizer takes a page from his erstwhile boss by assailing anyone, albeit with a richer vocabulary, who disagrees with him on his China-as-enemy stance as “a liar, a fool, a knave, an irredeemable globalist, or some combination thereof.” In his calmer moments, the author makes some good points, such as the fact that Ireland has become a haven for hiding billions of dollars in American corporate profits that more properly need to be taxed at home—but, as ever, underlying that charge is the demand that taxes be lowered. Arguable, too, is the author’s conviction that trade agreements should be term-limited and frequently renegotiated, a destabilizing strategy guaranteed to consume large amounts of diplomatic oxygen.

Red meat for the isolationist set.