THE FORBIDDEN BOOK

A girl runs away from her wedding and meets the Angel of Death.

Seventeen-year-old Sorel Kalmans, motherless and wealthy, does not want to marry the rebbe’s son. For one, the young people’s fathers arranged the match to strengthen both their business relationship and the Jewish communities of the (likely) 19th-century Russian town of Esrog and its surrounding shtetlach. More importantly, Sorel doesn’t recognize herself as a blushing bride—when she looks in the mirror, she sees a stranger. So she steals a stableboy’s clothes and runs away. A mysterious young man named Sam helps her survive her new vagabond life, but Isser Jacobs, the false name she chooses at random, also belongs, unfortunately, to a local boy who’s deeply embroiled in Sorel’s father’s licit and illicit business interests. Lamb’s sophomore novel contains fascinating magical elements drawn from Ashkenazi Jewish lore, such as dybbuks, angels, and demons, but confusing timelines and a muted and anticlimactic ultimate reveal weaken the story. Relatedly, Sorel herself is a blank cipher at the center of this slice of Yiddishkeit life, a character who plays others so much that readers never quite learn who she is, what she wants, and what is at the root of her motivation to leave.

An interesting frame for a story that ends up spinning its wheels.