BAD ANIMALS

A small-town Maine librarian gets into a peck of trouble.

Plot #1: Maeve Cosgrove is called to her supervisor’s office, where a woman from the Office of Family and Child Services has come to talk to her. One of the library’s regular visitors, a teen named Libby, has filed a complaint: Maeve has been watching her have sex with a boy in one of the library’s bathroom stalls. The girl is in foster care, and the boy is developmentally delayed, and Maeve insists it didn’t happen, but eventually it seems it more or less did, sort of. Maeve might be let off the hook, but if she wasn’t obsessed with the girl before, she certainly is now, and then she loses her job anyway, supposedly due to budget cuts. Welcome to Plot #2: Maeve has been writing letters to Harrison Riddles, a famous author who summers in Maine. She’s told him all about her beloved library and co-workers. Now, it turns out, he’s going to write a book based on the life of Willie, a Sudanese refugee who’s the boyfriend of Maeve’s fellow librarian Katrina. Since Maeve’s husband is perennially out of town on business and her daughter has flown the nest, Maeve, now jobless, is available to get very tangled up in this other situation. It takes a while to sink in that she is not an easy person to root for, but once it does, it complicates an already overcomplicated book, which touches on everything from abuse and empathy to literary appropriation, ventriloquizing, and the idea of the Magical Negro. A few chapters are narrated in first person by the characters, and toward the end the book floats the idea that it’s been authored by a real-life Maeve, hiding her secrets “in plain sight,” and then a strange last chapter suggests—well, you’ll have to figure it out.

Full of ideas, plot, verve, interesting scenes, and good writing, but just a little too full. A writer to watch.