SOME OTHER NOW

In the process of seeking a family, a teen may be breaking up somebody else’s.

Jessi Rumfield has always felt closer to Mel Cohen than to her own mom, who spent most of Jessi’s childhood so deep in depression that she was unable to be present for her daughter. Mel and her sons, Rowan and Luke, have been Jessi’s constants in life. But after Mel was diagnosed with an illness they called the Big Bad, Ro asked Jessi to leave the house, and nothing was ever the same again. Now it’s the summer after high school graduation, and Luke has turned up after months of silence, asking Jessi to do him a favor: pretend to be his girlfriend to make Mel, who is nearing the end of her life, happy. Except the last time they were girlfriend and boyfriend, Jessi and Luke’s relationship ruined things with Ro, and everything fell apart from there. Despite the intriguing premise, big reveals and hidden secrets are so obvious that they lose their emotional impact. Sections labeled “now” and “then” give structure and context to the narrative, but readers may nevertheless have trouble keeping track of what’s happening. The main characters are biracial in a predominantly White area, which sets them apart from the community and draws them together. Jessi is Black and White; Luke and Rowan’s maternal grandparents emigrated from the Philippines, and their father was presumably White.

A predictable heartstring puller.